Who Dropped Out of American Idol Top 26 Who Did Paige American is the cherished vocalist who mesmerized multitudes of admirers with his impressive talent on American Idol. Quit won over watchers across the nation with his spellbinding vocals and charismatic stage presence. His commitment to withdraw from the show shocked all, leaving his devotees devastated. However, Idol will always be remembered as an legend in the history of American Idol.